Imagine buying a toy for your child, something seemingly harmless like colored sand, only to discover it's contaminated with asbestos! This nightmare scenario is becoming increasingly real, prompting serious warnings about the safety of imported goods. After a recent asbestos scare involving children's play sand, experts are urging consumers to be extra cautious, especially with imported products, even those marketed for kids.
The initial alarm was triggered by the recall of several brands of colored play sand found to contain tremolite asbestos, a known carcinogen. The recall has since expanded to include products like the 'Rainbow Sand Art Toy,' with approximately 800 units sold nationwide at discount stores, and other sand craft kits. This is particularly alarming because it's illegal to import products containing asbestos! But here's where it gets controversial... how are these contaminated products slipping through the cracks?
According to University of Auckland law professor Alex Sims, we can't simply assume that laws are being followed. "We've just seen it with the colored sand, but I think to be honest, it's not sort of a product that people naturally thought would have asbestos in it." She emphasizes that while retailers and importers are responsible for conducting product checks, those checks aren't always happening consistently. There are numerous laws governing the safety of children's toys and specifically prohibiting the import of asbestos-containing items. "There's lots and lots of laws, but it is up to the people selling it and importing it to make sure that the law is being followed." And this is the part most people miss... the responsibility ultimately falls on businesses to ensure the products they sell are safe.
Sims points out that product safety issues are more common than consumers realize, often coming to light only after a near-tragedy. "What often happens is something happens... where some poor child almost dies and then they look into it, and then the prosecutions happens, but this after the fact." She suggests that proactive measures, such as spot checks by the Commerce Commission, could help identify unsafe products before they cause harm. However, she admits that the sheer volume of imported goods makes comprehensive monitoring incredibly challenging.
What happens if you've already purchased contaminated sand? If parents want to be reimbursed for the cost of asbestos testing or any necessary clean-up, Sims clarifies that the retailer, which in many cases is Kmart, is responsible under the Consumer Guarantees Act. "Under the Consumer Guarantees Act if a good is not safe, and if it's contaminated with asbestos it's not safe, then yes [you are entitled to] a refund of the money, but also the cost of the testing the cost of cleaning," she explains. "If the colour sand is all through a carpet and it can't be cleaned properly then the cost of replacing that carpet as well." Getting that compensation, however, might not be easy, and Sims would be surprised if the retailer readily covered all costs. "The only real way at the moment is for someone to go to the disputes tribunal." Schools are also covered by the Consumer Guarantees Act, offering some protection for educational institutions.
Despite the existing laws, Sims stresses that consumers must be vigilant. "Unfortunately the laws don't work...yes, we've got laws, but then as we've seen here, they're not protecting anybody, so it is buyer beware." With the holiday season approaching, she recommends opting for simpler, more traditional toys, such as wooden items without paint, as a safer alternative.
MBIE (Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment) product safety spokesman Ian Caplin stated that the Ministry is collaborating with retailers of children's sand products to investigate supply chains and pinpoint the origin of the contaminated sand. The Ministry reiterated that retailers are responsible for selling safe products and that importing asbestos-containing products without a permit is illegal. Kmart, notably, did not respond to requests for comment regarding its sand products.
This situation raises serious questions about import regulations, product testing procedures, and corporate responsibility. Should there be stricter regulations and more frequent testing of imported goods? Is it fair to place the burden of ensuring product safety solely on consumers? What more should be done to prevent these dangerous products from reaching our shelves and, more importantly, our children? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
(Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.)
